Tag: John Sugden

9 Emmerdale characters we want to see more of in 2025 – from John Sugden to PC Swirling

A brand new year in Emmerdale is always an exciting prospect and it’s got us thinking about the characters want to see more of in 2025.

There’s a real mixture of locals on our list. Some are legacy characters who have become a little redundant in recent years and need revitilising. Others are newcomers to the village that we’re keen to get to know more. And then there’s a non-resident who we’re desperate to become a permanent fixture.

Here are our nine folk who deserve more screen time next year…

We want to see a different side to John Sugden (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale characters we want to see in 2025: John Sugden

John Sugden’s arrival to the village in August 2024 came with high hopes. As the long lost son of an Emmerdale icon, this was the chance to put the Sugdens back on the map. But four months on and we’re still waiting for something – anything – exciting to happen.

Right now, John isn’t bringing an awful amount to Emmerdale. We get that he’s an enigma, and self-confessed lone wolf. We don’t even mind he’s moody and defensive. But he’s just so boring. Even John’s relationship with Aaron feels like it’s going through the motions. If you compare it to the passion of Robron, there’s no energy or spark.

But there has to be more to John than what we’ve been shown so far. That explanation he gave Aaron about Aidan Moore being his lost love felt too neat for our liking. If you ask us he’s lying and we want to know why. Is this guy even John Sugden?!

We’re hoping Emmerdale are going to solve the mystery and give us a reason to invest in John as a character. Otherwise he might as well get back in that campervan and carry on driving.

Vic is being wasted as a character (Credit: ITV)

Victoria Sugden

While we’re on the subject of Sugdens, isn’t it time poor Victoria had a decent storyline? She’s barely on screen these days, and when she does pop up it’s normally to interfere in other folks’ business.

If you look past her being a nosey old nag, Vic is an important character in Emmerdale’s history. She’s one of its longest-serving residents and has lived in the village since she was born.

What we’d like is 2025 is to see Victoria lighten up a bit (okay, a lot) and get a life of her own. Perhaps an exciting new career opportunity or how about bring back her ex-husband Adam Barton? They made a great couple and we think he’d be lovely with her little Harry.

PC Swirling is popular amongst the fans (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale characters we want to see in 2025: PC Swirling

Fan favourite PC Swirling has been policing the Dales on and off for 20 years. We think that kind of loyal service should be rewarded. So how about making him a permanent character? We think he would be a marvelous addition.

The local copper recently showed viewers his softer side after arresting Cain Dingle for assault. Sensing Cain was troubled, Swirling got him to open up about Moira’s brain tumour diagnosis and shared he’d been through similar heartache with his aunt. And remember how he turned up to pay his respects at Zak’s funeral? He’s clearly a good egg.

Emmerdale could make more use of Swirling by moving him into the village. He could bring Mrs Swirling with him too, if she exists. We’d also love to see him teaming up with a few of the locals, particularly Kim Tate.

We would like to see Dawn smile in 2025 (Credit: ITV)

Dawn Fletcher

The past 12 months have not been kind to Dawn. She’s had to cope with baby Evan’s cancer, Will and Rose’s toxic war and now her marriage to Billy is in crisis following his ongoing involvement in illegal boxing. Would a happier 2025 be too much to ask?

Ever since Dawn arrived in the Dales six years ago she’s been blighted by bad luck and misery. But we would really like the chance to see a lighter, more bubbly side to her character.

Dawn’s got all the makings to be a brilliant barmaid behind The Woolpack bar. And we’d love to see her make friends with some of the fellow mums in the village, perhaps have a long overdue girly night out?

Caleb’s character is confusing (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale characters we want to see in 2025: Caleb Miligan

Ruby’s character development has been one of the greatest triumphs of 2024, but Caleb remains something of a frustrating mystery. One minute he’s hell bent on toppling Kim Tate’s empire. Next, it’s all been forgotten about.

Just who is the real Caleb? Is he and out and out lying cheat and scoundrel? Or does have actually have a moral compass?

Next year we might get to find out as two secrets threaten to cause carnage. The first being Ruby’s betrayal with Cain. Even though Caleb’s repeatedly cheated on her, would he forgive Ruby for sleeping with his own brother?

And then of course, there’s Anthony’s abuse of Ruby and the question of whether Caleb isn’t actually Steph’s father. This revelation is going to destroy Caleb. And we wouldn’t be surprised if Caleb tried to put Anthony in the grave before the cancer finishes him off.

Gabby has gone under the radar (Credit: ITV)

Gabby Thomas

Where is Gabby these days? She’s gone completely under the radar since getting together with Vinny and we’d like her back.

The couple still appear to be in the honeymoon period and are proving the doubters wrong. But do they have what it takes to go the distance? 2025 will give us that answer.

Gabby now deserves a prominent storyline of her own. Will she end up getting drawn into the drama at Home Farm? Kim is going to need someone in her corner, and who better than her canny protegee? Gabs has learnt from the best and has the ability to take anyone on.

There are tough times ahead for Jacob (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale characters we want to see in 2025: Jacob Gallagher

Emmerdale has confirmed Jacob will be taking centre stage in a gripping new plot for 2025. And it’s about time too!

A special standalone episode will follow the medical student as he’s pushed to his limits during the first day working in a busy A&E department. We’ve long been fans of actor Joe Warren-Plant and think this is going to be his time to shine.

As well embarking on a tough new career, Jacob is set to start a romance with long-time friend Sarah Sugden. It’s surprising the writers have waited so long to put these two together as they really suit one another.

Also, we suspect Jacob is going to be involved in mum Leyla’s departure from the village. So it looks as if we’ll be seeing a lot of him in the next few weeks. Hurrah!

Ross has been up to no good again (Credit: ITV)

Ross Barton

Mike Parr must be one of the busiest actors in soap right now, he’s barely been off our screen. Not that we’re complaining – we’d like a little less of Ross’s predictable bad boy antics.

The moments we’ve warmed to Ross most are the scenes he’s shared with April Windsor. Because of their shared history, their bond feels genuine and we like how Ross has become a stepfather figure/confidant for the troubled teen. Plus it’s always a delight to see the brilliant Amelia Flanagan (aka April) being given a meatier storyline.

But what we’d really like in 2025 is find out more about those six years Ross spent in Liverpool with his late girlfriend Rebecca White and her son Seb. What really happened to split them up? And did Ross have anything to do with Bex’s untimely passing? Let’s fill in the gaps and delve a little deeper.

Steph’s life is set to implode (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale characters we want to see in 2025: Steph Miligan

The Miligans are the family to watch as we go into 2025, and Steph in particular.

We really like what we’ve seen of the newcomer so far. She’s calculating, uncompromising, feisty and fearless – basically her mum’s mini me. But her whole world could be about to come crashing down.

Like Caleb, Steph is still in the dark over the abuse Ruby suffered at the hands of Anthony. And we’re yet to discover whether Steph’s biological father is in fact her grandad, who she idolises. If the truth does out, everything Steph has ever known would be shattered in an instant.

Might Steph team up with Caleb to take down evil Anthony? Or exact her own revenge on the perverted OAP?

Read more: Is Steph Anthony’s daughter?Â

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 7.30pm, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.

Classic Emmerdale usually airs every weekday on ITV3 at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Visit our Facebook pageÂ @emmerdaleinsiderÂ for all the latest Emmerdale news, gossip and spoilers and let us know what you think! Or find us on TwitterÂ @emmerdaleinside

1st January 2025
Emmerdale storylines that need to be tied up in 2025: Moira’s brain tumour, the Aidan Moore mystery and who is Steph’s real father

A new year has dawned in Emmerdale and we’re excited for all the drama that’s going to unfold over the course of 2025.

It’s also got us thinking about the current storylines and unresolved matters we’d like to see come to a conclusion over the next 12 months. And some preferably sooner rather than later.

Here are eight plots that need to be tied up this year…

Fans suspect John is deceiving Aaron (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale storylines that need to be tied up: The mystery of Aidan Moore

Please, please, please can we get closure on the whole Aidan Moore mystery and find out who he really was/is? There has to be a more to the story than him being John Sugden’s dead ex.

What we know so far – according to John – is that he and Aidan served in the army together. They fell in love, but kept their romance under wraps through fear of being ostracised. Aidan was tragically killed in a bomb blast while they were out in Afghanistan, which left John bereft.

But even though John has confessed his love to Aaron and chucked Aidan’s dog tag away in the woods, we’re not buying it. Something doesn’t feel right and we suspect John is lying.

Fans are still speculating that John is actually Aidan, an imposter sent by Aaron’s imprisoned ex Robert to cause carnage. While this theory seems a little wild, we’d like to think the truth is more exciting than a tale of lost love. So let’s be having it.

We want a happier and healthier 2025 for Moira (Credit: ITV)

Moira’s brain tumour

First off, we think Natalie J Robb has been superb throughout the whole Moira brain tumour storyline. The actress’s portrayal of her character’s traumatic health battle deserves all the awards going.

But we don’t want another year of watching one of our favourite characters suffering.

Although Moira’s surgery to remove her tumour was ultimately a success, she still has to undergo a grueling course of radiotherapy. Wouldn’t it be wonderful if the treatment worked and she was given the all clear?

We would love nothing more than for Moira to be able to put this traumatic chapter behind her and look to the future.

Cain and Ruby should never mention their affair again (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale storylines that need to be tied up: Cain and Ruby’s affair

Cain and Ruby’s drunken hook-up was neither one’s finest hour. Since then the pair have been desperate that Moira never discovers what they were doing while she was undergoing life-saving brain surgery.

And we are in full agreement.

Affair reveals in soap have historically made for thrilling viewing, but absolutely no good can come out of this betrayal being outed. It would cause maximum pain and distress to all involved. Moira needs to focus on getting better, Ruby’s already in hell, and it would be a shame to ruin their lovely friendship. Cain and Caleb we care less about, but that would surely be the end of the brother’s bond.

What Cain and Ruby did was a stupid mistake, let’s just leave it at that and move on.

Who will Steph’s father turn out to be? (Credit: ITV)

Who’s Steph’s father?

It’s the most horrifying who’s the daddy storyline, but we need to know the truth. Is Steph the daughter of Caleb or Anthony?

Steph has always been led to believe she was conceived on the day of Ruby’s 16th birthday. But now viewers know this was the day Anthony forced himself on his terrified daughter. And it wasn’t the first time he’d done it.

Ruby had also started dating Caleb at the time, which means there’s a high chance Steph is his child. But there’s only one way to determine her paternity, and that’s with a DNA test.

We really hope Steph doesn’t turn out to be Anthony’s, because the storyline is twisted enough as it is. But it certainly would make for more of a dramatic reveal.

Anthony must be made to pay for what he’s done (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale storylines that need to be tied up: Anthony getting away with it

There’s no way we get to end of next year without retribution for Ruby. And that means Anthony being exposed for the evil abuser he is.

The old man is on borrowed time having been given a terminal cancer diagnosis, so this needs to happen fast. But we can’t bear the thought of Anthony taking his sordid secret to the grave and Ruby not having the chance to see her father punished for his despicable crimes.

Let him end his days in jail we say!

We have to know if Rebecca was murdered by Ross (Credit: ITV)

What happened to Rebecca White

Ross’s bombshell about the death of his former girlfriend Rebecca hit us hard. It was out of the blue and brutal.

During a chat with Charity, Ross revealed Rebecca had died suddenly during a routine surgery, leaving little Seb motherless. The lad was removed from Ross’s care and is now being raised by an aunt of Rebecca’s in Bristol.

But there has to be a reason why the show’s writers decided to kill off such a memorable character and the mother of Robert Sugden’s son. Does this pave the way for Robert’s long-awaited return? Or is there something more sinister at play? Could it be that Ross is telling fibs and he actually played a part in Rebecca’s untimely end?

Questions need to be answered that will either confirm or deny any speculation about Ross being a murderer.

Nate deserved a better send off (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale storylines that need to be tied up: Nate’s unfinished business

We think Emmerdale did Nate Robinson dirty by giving him such a rubbish exit.

The character, played by actor Jurrell Carter, ditched the village in September 2024 to start a new life in Shetland. But his hurried off-screen departure made absolutely no sense.

Nate had just decided to give his marriage to Tracy another go. But then Cain got it into his head that Nate was sleeping with Moira and violently attacked his son. When a fire later broke out in Butler’s barn, viewers feared that Nate had been killed off in the deadly blaze. But no, apparently Nate just slipped away quietly to Scotland without telling anyone.

Little Frankie is overdue a visit from her daddy, so why doesn’t Nate pop back for a visit? And then he might get the chance to say a proper goodbye to his loved ones. And get an apology from Cain. That is, unless he is actually dead…

Billy and Dawn need to break up (Credit: ITV)

Dawn and Billy’s marriage

You know that expression ‘flogging a dead horse’? That’s how we feel about Dawn and Billy‘s marriage. While we agree 2024 was brutal with baby Evan’s cancer battle and Will’s shock death, these two just aren’t right together any more. And there’s no point pretending otherwise.

Marriages in Soapland rarely go the distance, so what would be the problem if Billy and Dawn called it quits? All they seem to do lately is drag one another down. Split them up before the rot really sets in so they can remain mates and focus on co-parenting their kids.

A clean break from Billy might also breathe some new life into downtrodden Dawn. Who needs a man to have fun? Unless it’s Ross Barton. In that case we’d quite like to see Dawn getting it on with the village bad boy.

Read more: Every Emmerdale birth in the soap’s history

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights at 7.30pm on ITV, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.Â

Classic Emmerdale usually airs weekdays at 6am, and 6.30am on ITV3, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Follow our Facebook pageÂ @EmmerdaleInsiderÂ for the latest Emmerdale news, spoilers and gossip. Or find us on TwitterÂ @EmmerdaleInside. Let us know what you think!

1st January 2025
Emmerdale review of the week: Tom’s banged up, John’s opening up, and Will needs to man up!

Our Emmerdale review this week looked like being a tough one. After all, this week’s episodes had to follow the emotional upheaval of Ruby’s story last week.

But despite the bar being set very high, we reckon Emmerdale pulled it off, thanks to the drama of Tom King’s trial.

Here’s what we thought of this week in our Emmerdale review.

Things are finally getting better for Paddy but it was nice to revisit his story (Credit: ITV)

Unlikely friendships in our Emmerdale review

There’s very little we like more in soap than unlikely friendships, so we really enjoyed Belle going to Paddy for advice when Tom tried to take his own life.

Paddy of course had his own struggle with suicidal thoughts and it was good to see the ongoing effects of that heart-wrenching story. And we loved how sweet he was with Belle, reassuring her and making sure she was all right.

Tom faced justice (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale review: Tom’s trial

We’ve all been waiting for abuser Tom King to face justice for the ordeal he’s subjected poor Belle too. And the moment finally came this week when he was in the dock, charged with assault and coercive control.

The episode featuring the trial took an interesting approach. The focus wasn’t on Tom – instead it was on the jurors who had to decide his fate. It made for a fascinating episode as the jury members debated whether Tom was guilty.

However, we did feel the whole thing was just too quick. It’s only a matter of weeks since Tom’s arrest, the trial itself took up just one double episode, and Tom was sentenced and taken off to jail on the same day. A year-long story has been neatly wrapped up like a Christmas present. We couldn’t help feeling a bit cheated about it.

John Sugden’s dog tag with the name Aidan Moore

The truth about Aidan Moore revealed! Or was it?

We still love moody John Sugden, and we really enjoyed his camping trip with Aaron this week. We liked the pair opening up to one another and the reveal that John was in love with Aidan – the man whose dog tag he’s kept.

Except, we can’t help thinking there’s more to this story. Is John telling the truth? We’re looking forward to learning more.

Amelia’s gone to Leicester with Esther

Amelia Spencer waved goodbye to the village this week. Her exit was a bit of a damp squib and also felt slightly rushed. She’s been a part of Emmerdale since she was a little girl and we’ll miss her.

Stop whining (credit: ITV)

Dawn and Billy

The Dawn and Billy bickering rumbles on. Evan’s allowed home again, which we think is good news, though frankly at this stage we couldn’t care less. Will Clemmie and Lucas ever be allowed back to school? Where are Clemmie and Lucas, come to that?

Come on, Will. Stand up for yourself. (Credit: ITV)

Man up, Will!

Remember how Will used to be? Ex-con, protective dad, didn’t think twice about moving the body of a dead policeman, kept Kim on her toes… Now he’s wafting about Home Farm, marching to the beat of financial adviser Peter’s drum. If Peter says jump, Will asks how high. It’s very out of character.

We can’t believe we’re saying this, but this is what it’s come to. While the other men of Emmerdale – including Will’s son-in-law Billy, are dripping with toxic masculinity, we can’t help thinking Will could do with, well, manning up a bit!

It’s time to grow a pair, Mr Taylor. Tell Peter to sling his hook and take your chances with whoever’s calling the shots behind the scenes.

Speaking of which, our guesses about the identity of Mr I-Live-In-A-Different-Time-Zone Where Phones and Email Don’t Work is, are becoming increasingly outlandish. Is it Joe Tate? Jean Tate? Steve Marchant? Another long-lost child of Frank’s. Kim herself?! We just hope it’s not Caleb. Oh god, it’s Caleb isn’t it?

Read more: Who’s leaving Emmerdale? All the cast exits, arrivals and returns

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 7.30pm, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.

Classic Emmerdale usually airs every weekday on ITV3 at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Visit our Facebook pageÂ @emmerdaleinsiderÂ for all the latest Emmerdale news, gossip and spoilers and let us know what you think! Or find us on TwitterÂ @emmerdaleinside

21st December 2024
Fans beg for Robert Sugden to return in 2025 – hereâ€™s whether a comeback is possible

Emmerdale fans aren’t enjoying Aaron Dingle’s romance with John Sugden and have called for Aaron’s ex, Robert Sugden, to return next year.

Aaron first hooked up with John in August, after arranging to meet him via a dating app. It was later revealed that John was a Sugden and the secret half brother of Robert.

Now, with both Aaron and John having a link to Robert, fans want Robert to return to the Dales in 2025. But where is Robert and is a comeback possible?

Where is Robert Sugden?

Robert left Emmerdale in 2019 after being sent to prison for killing his sister’s rapist.

During a night out, Victoria Sugden met a man called Lee Posner. He wouldn’t take no for an answer and later he raped Victoria in her own home.

Victoria left it a while before reporting the attack meaning there was no physical evidence and the case was eventually dropped. However, Lee continued to taunt Victoria and her family and one day, Robert lost it and hit Lee over the head with a shovel.

Lee survived the attack long enough to tell police Robert had been responsible, but later died from a intracerebral haemorrhage. Robert was sentenced to 14 years in prison, leaving fans devastated that Robron was no more.

Emmerdale fans miss Robron (Credit: ITV/Shutterstock)

Fans demand a Robert Sugden return

Scenes this week have seen Aaron and John confess their love to each other. While some fans were moved by the scenes, many couldn’t help but point out the lack of chemistry between the pair and reminisce about Aaron’s previous relationship with Robert.

“NOOO WE ALL WANT ROBERT,” one fan said on Instagram. Another added: “I donâ€™t like Aaron with John, it will always be Robert and Aaron!! Please come back Robert!!”

“No one will compare to Robert,” a third fan wrote, with a fourth writing: “Aaron belongs to Robert. You need to bring them back together for good!”

A fifth fan said: “I wish Robert would come back. Aaron and Robert were perfect together!,” with another writing: “John is no Robert!! Bring back Robert in 2025, Aaron belongs to Robert.”

Could Robert and Aaron be reunited in 2025? (Credit: ITV/Shutterstock)

Is a comeback for Robert possible?

Although, it’s only been 5 years since he was sentenced to 14 years in prison, this is soap land where anything is possible. Viewers may also remember that back in 2021, Lee’s brother Luke revealed to their mum Wendy that on the day Lee was attacked by Robert, Lee had beaten Luke up after discovering he was in a relationship with a man.

Luke said he fought back, resulting in Lee falling down and hitting his head. Hours later he was attacked by Robert. If Luke’s confession becomes known, Robert could potentially get out of jail on appeal.

Robert’s name has cropped up a lot lately, with fans hoping it means he’s on his way back. One theory is that John isn’t really who he says he is. Fans have speculated that he could have been in prison with Robert. Could Robert be the key to unlocking the truth about John Sugden and Aidan Moore?

In addition, Ross Barton made a return to the village recently after six years away and he revealed that Rebecca White had died. Rebecca was the mother of Robert’s son Seb â€“ another reason for Robert to come back.

The most recent Robert was played by Ryan Hawley, who has starred in All Creatures Great and Small, Silent Witness and Casualty since leaving Emmerdale.

Read more: The Sugden family tree in Emmerdale

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 7.30pm.

Classic Emmerdale usually airs every weekday on ITV3 at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Visit our Facebook pageÂ @emmerdaleinsiderÂ for all the latest Emmerdale news, gossip and spoilers and let us know what you think! Or find us on TwitterÂ @emmerdaleinside

19th December 2024
As Aaron and John confess their love to each other, fans fail to get behind â€˜forcedâ€™ romance

A recent Emmerdale episode saw John Sugden and Aaron Dingle confess their love for each other, but fans aren’t buying it.

John arrived in the Dales in the summer. Unaware that John was related to his ex-husband Robert Sugden, Aaron arranged to meet up with John via a dating app.

Aaron and John have been in a slow burning romance since, with things stepping up a notch this week. But fans think the relationship is too ‘forced’ and can’t get behind it.

Aaron and John confessed their love for each other (Credit: ITV)

Aaron and John said the L word

This week, Aaron and John have been getting close to nature by camping in the woods. While Aaron was initially reluctant to go on the trip, he relented when he saw how much it meant to John.

The two have become closer during the trip. Aaron has opened up about how his abuser Gordon used to take him camping, while John spoke to Aaron about the mysterious Aidan Moore.

Yesterday’s episode (Wednesday December 18) saw the L-bomb dropped. Aaron informed John that he was in it for the long run and said that he thought he was in love with him. Fortunately for Aaron, he didn’t embarrass himself as John admitted he felt the same way.

Viewers aren’t fans of the couple (Credit: ITV)

Fans can’t get behind the romance

Emmerdale fans aren’t a fan of Aaron and John as a couple, with many citing the lack of chemistry.

One fan wrote on X: “There’s zero chemistry between Aaron and John. It just doesn’t work,” while another said: “Even Aaron thinks John is boring…lol, I don’t think even Emmerdale believe they are selling this snoozefest.”

Over on Instagram, a third fan agreed, writing: “My gosh, this relationship is so forced. These 2 have no chemistry unlike Robert and Aaron.” A fourth viewer added: “Donâ€™t like John! Something not right with him! Plus these 2 donâ€™t gel together at all for me.”

Another added: “Iâ€™m just not feeling these two as a couple, the chemistry is not right.” While a sixth fan said: “Iâ€™m having difficulty liking this pair. I like John as a person, but he and Aaron donâ€™t have chemistry. It seems forced.”

Read more:Â Christmas Spoilers for Emmerdale: Terror at Home Farm!

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights at 7.30pm on ITV, with an early release at 7am on ITVX.Â

Classic Emmerdale usually airs weekdays at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm on ITV3.Â

Follow our Facebook page @EmmerdaleInsider for the latest Emmerdale spoilers, news and gossip. Or find us on Twitter @EmmerdaleInside. Let us know what you think!

19th December 2024
Viewers believe John is definitely â€˜lyingâ€™ about Aidan Moore after he opens up to Aaron – so just what is he hiding?

In last night’s episode of Emmerdale (Tuesday, December 17), Â John opened up to Aaron about his past with the mysterious Aidan Moore. But the conversation has left viewers more convinced than ever that he is lying.

When John first arrived on our screens earlier this year, fans were quick to assume he was hiding something. That’s when we were treated to the mystery of the dog tag with the name Aidan Moore.

John explained that away as someone he cared about who died in Afghanistan as he couldn’t save him. But is he being honest?

For months fans have been deeming John as the ‘fake Sugden’ as they believe there is a bigger secret at play. But exactly what that is remains unknown.

Fans are convinced that, in Emmerdale, John is lying about who he is (Credit: ITV)

Fans still believe John is lying in Emmerdale

While many fans have criticised the show for appearing to try and copy Aaron’s relationship with Robert, some others feel this may be a hint at John’s true plans.

There are many theories out there; Robert somehow wronged John and so he is taking revenge against those he loved, or maybe John actually is Aidan Moore. Either way, there has to be more than we know. Right?

Taking to X (formerly known as Twitter) after last night’s episode, viewers all could agree on one thing; John is hiding a big secret.

One wrote: “You could reveal John was a serial killer and I would believe it. It’s got to be one of two things with him. Either the writers worry they won’t find a better pairing than Aaron and Robert so they’re trying to write him as the ‘perfect guy,’ or it’s intentional and he is a threat.”

Another added: “So we’re all in agreement that John has stolen Victoria’s identity and isn’t actually him, right?”

A third penned: “I don’t trust John at all. Sorry. He’s lying and I get pure bad vibes from him.”

John has expressed interest in everyone Robert loved – coincidence? (Credit: ITV)

Could it lead to a happy return?

However, one fan hoped that whatever his secret is, it will lead to the reunion we all want – Robert back in the village.

They wrote: “There is something off about John. I don’t trust him at all. And now I’m worried about Aaron because he lets his guard down too easily. I just hope the whole storyline is leading to a return for Robert.”

So could John or Aidan have served time with Robert inside? It would have given him the access to all of those he cares about most in the village. So far, it’s definitely a strong contender.

And a Robert return is definitely what we all would like to see. If Emmerdale bosses can bring back Ross Barton this year, why can’t they do the same for Robert?

So, is John being honest? Or is there more to come out about the new Sugden?

Read more: Lisa Riley hits out at ‘fake’ Instagram posts claiming she is selling diet pills

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights at 7.30pm on ITV, with an early release at 7am on ITVX.Â

Classic Emmerdale usually airs weekdays at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm on ITV3.Â

Follow our Facebook page @EmmerdaleInsider for the latest Emmerdale spoilers, news and gossip. Or find us on Twitter @EmmerdaleInside. Let us know what you think!

18th December 2024
Emmerdale fans believe John ‘really isâ€™ Aidan Moore

Emmerdale fans genuinely believe that John Sugden lied about who Aidan Moore is and that he’s actually the man himself.

There’s been a lot of speculation as to who Aidan Moore could be, and despite John providing the answers… fans aren’t convinced he’s telling the truth. Fair enough.

Aaron opened up to John (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale fans reckon John himself is Aidan Moore

Ever since they spotted John acting really guarded around a dog tag with the name ‘Aidan Moore’ on it, fans started to wonder who Aidan could be.

With John eventually admitting to Vic that Aidan was an old army friend who died, the way he looked at the dog tag again last night (Monday, December 16), suggested that there was more to the story. Something is definitely suss, that’s for sure!

Now, fans are convinced that John himself is actually Aidan and has been trying to fool Aaron and Vic with a different identity all along.

One fan wrote: “I think John is really Aidan.”

Another fan agreed and suggested: “Imposter John Sugden.”

A third person added: “Without Robert there is no drama, because surely Aidan Moore is really John or his ex lover. Aaron and John go bonding about the loss of their loved ones, they say ILY in the woods and they surely disappear for weeks (until next year.) That’s not a good story.”

John’s been rather guarded about Aidan (Credit: ITV)

So, who actually is Aidan Moore?

Right, so here’s all we know so far. Aidan was an old friend of John’s, meeting him in the army.

While out in Afghanistan, Aidan got injured and John had promised to save him. However, his injuries were too severe and he died, with John breaking his promise.

John couldn’t live with the guilt and decided to leave the army and head off to live in a campervan.

But, John is still so guarded and secretive when it comes to this dog tag! There must be more to the story, right?

But, who was Aidan Moore? Or, who is Aidan Moore? Is John the guy himself? Just what is he keeping from Aaron and Vic?

Read more:Â Whoâ€™s leaving Emmerdale? All the exits, arrivals and returns planned

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 7.30pm, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.

Classic Emmerdale usually airs every weekday on ITV3 at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Visit our Facebook pageÂ @emmerdaleinsiderÂ for all the latest Emmerdale news, gossip and spoilers and let us know what you think! Or find us on Twitter @emmerdaleinside

17th December 2024
Emmerdale John isnâ€™t in love with Aaron – itâ€™s all a revenge plot, fans predict

Could John Sugden in Emmerdale actually be playing Aaron? A very convincing fan theory thinks so.

When John arrived in the village earlier this year, it felt there was more to meet the eye. But nothing has really happened… yet.

Last night’s episode saw John once again look at the dog tag he keeps with him; with the name Aidan Moore. And that’s exactly why a lot of Emmerdale fans think he is hiding something more sinister.

A new theory on social media predicts that John’s character is all a sham, and he is actually there to get revenge on someone else; Robert Sugden.

Is Emmerdale John hiding something? (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale John is out for revenge, predicts fans.

After last night’s episode which saw John take Aaron on an unwanted camping trip, fans can’t help but feel there’s more to come.

One fan wrote on X (formerly known as Twitter): “Until now I genuinely thought it was just poor casting. But for the first time I’m convinced John is up to something. Some revenge plot against Robert, because he is so cold to Aaron.”

For a while fans have complained about the lack of chemistry between Aaron and John, and while it may have been down to everyone comparing them to the loved Robron, maybe it was actually supposed to be that way.

Robert is currently serving a 14-year prison sentence for the murder of Lee Posner. But fans have been desperate for him to return.

With this new theory, could Robert have had a history with John himself? Or did he have one with the mysterious Aidan Moore? And John is out for revenge over whatever happened.

If John does know Robert, it makes sense that he inserted himself into the village as a Sugden. He may have heard all about their family from Rob, so he knew exactly who to talk to and what to say when he arrived.

Fans think Emmerdale John Sugden is out for revenge. (Credit: ITV)

Everyone notices the similarities in both relationships

One thing that has not escaped fans’ attention is the way it seems Emmerdale are trying to recreate Robert and Aaron’s relationship.

The pair had their first kiss beside a broken down car on a lay-by, exactly like Robert and Aaron, and now they’re confessing their feelings for each other in the woods. Just like Robert and Aaron.

So, if the revenge theory is true, could John maybe know Robert from prison? Perhaps he spent some time inside with him, they got close, and Rob told him all about his relationship with Aaron.

If so, then Aaron could be set for a bigger and more dangerous storyline next year than anyone is ready for. And just maybe, this is what we need to get Rob back on our screens.

Do you think there is more to John than meets the eye?

Read more: Christmas Spoilers for Emmerdale: Terror at Home Farm!

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights at 7.30pm on ITV, with an early release at 7am on ITVX.Â

Classic Emmerdale usually airs weekdays at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm on ITV3.Â

Follow us on our Facebook page @EmmerdaleInsider for the latest Emmerdale spoilers, news and gossip. Or find us on Twitter @EmmerdaleInside. Let us know what you think!

17th December 2024
Aaron and John need to split up, fans insist

Fans of Emmerdale have shared their distaste for Aaron and John as a couple… once again demanding that they split up before their relationship goes any further.

This follows last night’s episode (airing Wednesday, November 4), in which John could be seen briefly as Ross popped around to see Aaron and Mack.

After sending Ross packing, John headed off too. It was then revealed that Mack was the one who took Jade’s money.

However, fans were more distracted by the presence of John, reminding them of a relationship that, for many, is one of the soap’s least-liked pairings.

John and Aaron are a thing… but many fans are wishing they weren’t (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale fans slam John and Aaron as they demand ‘Robron’ returns

Writing on the social media site X, fans shared their disappointment that the soap was continuing to plough ahead with Aaron and John’s relationship.

Many, of course, are still holding out for the reunion of ‘Robron’ – Aaron and ex-husband Robert.

“Many of us want Robert back in Ryan Hawley’s face. We don’t care about John and Aaron as ‘couple’ nor about John as character. I don’t know what Emmerdale was waiting for? good buzz? there is only negativity and boredom. Break them up and give Aaron a better story,” said one fan.

“Can’t stand John and Aaron together they just don’t have chemistry imo,” claimed another.

“I think Aaron will feature in one if not two storylines the first will probably be the continuation of Ross’s boxing storyline and the second will have to do with Chas and her new/old romance and it’s aftermath. Because unless Robert returns he and John will be boring,” said a third.

“As far as we like Aaron,we know that he would never have been with John knowing that he is a Sugden, I still don’t know why they are together, because like everything happens off screen,” agreed another.

John and Aaron are about to get even more loved-up (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale spoilers: Love is in the air

This comes as recent Emmerdale spoilers have revealed that Aaron and John will confess their love during an upcoming camping trip.

After John takes Aaron out on a getaway in the woods, their relationship deepens. It’s then that the pair admit their love for each other.

Buckle up, John and Aaron haters!

Read more:Â Whoâ€™s leaving Emmerdale?

[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFPiLYKqBP4?version=3&rel=1&showsearch=0&showinfo=1&iv_load_policy=1&fs=1&hl=en-GB&autohide=2&wmode=transparent]

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 7.30pm, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.

Classic Emmerdale usually airs every weekday on ITV3 at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Visit our Facebook pageÂ @emmerdaleinsiderÂ for all the latest Emmerdale news, gossip and spoilers and let us know what you think! Or find us on TwitterÂ @emmerdaleinside

5th December 2024
Emmerdale spoilers: Aaron and John’s camping trip takes an unexpected turn with a love confession

Emmerdale spoilers for Monday December 16 to Friday December 20 reveal that love is in the air for Aaron Dingle and John Sugden this Christmas. What’s the festive season without a little bit of romance, eh?!

The week doesn’t start off all that well for the pair when John surprises Aaron with a camping trip. But hey, things can only get better, right?!

Aaron and John go camping (Credit: ITV)

John takes Aaron camping in Emmerdale spoilers

Given John Sugden likes to live out of his van, a spot of camping in the wilderness is right up his street. Aaron however doesn’t do camping. Come on, you’ve been on the run that many times, you’ve slept in far worse places, mate!

Aaron’s reaction is not quite what John was hoping for when he tells him about the surprise trip. But John doesn’t let that stop him and he drags Aaron off anyway.

The couple find themselves talking more openly than ever before whilst out in nature. It makes their emotional connection deeper than ever before too.

With John and Aaron finding some happiness, they confess that they love each other. So sweet!

However if you ask us, that means Emmerdale plans to ruin their union…

The guys say ‘I love you’ (Credit: ITV)

Robert return on Christmas Day speculated

After show boss Iain Macleod said in an interview with Digital Spy back in September: “This Christmas, there is a huge surprise arrival on Christmas Day,” many fans have speculated it’s the return of Robert Sugden.

Currently serving time in prison for killing sister Victoria’s rapist Lee Posner, Robert was Aaron’s one true love. They weathered many a storm together, but Rob let Aaron go when he was sent down.

Aaron has proved he’s not quite forgotten Robert – as displayed when he found out Rebecca had died and left Robert’s son, who Aaron doted on, without a mother. John picked up on his residual feelings for Robert and it made things awkward.

But after actually talking about it, they decided to move on and move forward together. This declaration of love is the next stage in that. But could Robert return and mess everything up again? Who knows, but it’s certainly what the fans want!

Read more: Who’s leaving Emmerdale? All the cast exits, arrivals and returns

Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 7.30pm, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.

Classic Emmerdale usually airs every weekday on ITV3 at 6am and 6.30am, plus 1.40pm and 2.10pm.

Visit our Facebook page @emmerdaleinsider for all the latest Emmerdale news, gossip and spoilers and let us know what you think! Or find us on Twitter @emmerdaleinside

5th December 2024